I'm sure this is one of many similar posts, using ideas we've thrown back and forth. This may get long, but I want to keep the thread of conversation together.
==========H==========
I was thinking about all the people that choose a particular way of life, at least for a period of time, because they think it's cool. Like skinheads who think they're being tough, but don't really understand what they're appearing to stand for. Or even southerners who fly the rebel flag. Or particularly Christians who believe what they want to believe, regardless of what the Bible says. Or goth kids. Or whatever. I don't like it when people don't think.
So I want to use this to really push people - make them angry - find out why. So it bothers you that we killed God? Why?
==========R==========
The question: if God exists why does s/he allow so much pain, has always been a moot question for me. Freewill is a cop out. God may as well be dead.
God is a means to an end. At least in our society. A means to be elected. A means for happiness and joy. A wall to cry to. But that's something I suppose. To me God is the invisible thread that binds the elements together. A meme. I'm creating my own spirituality. Embracing primal pagan impulses. Light and dark. Highlight and Shadow.
The urge to love is the urge to love. Imagine what our society would be like if we didn't have laws or socially accepted forms of love. Freely able to express genuine love however we pleased. Off subject a bit, but Xianity censors love.
Xianity presupposes a natural social and physical order of the world. Men have dominion over women, humans have dominion over animal. What if that was turned upside down. Aliens don't exist blah blah blah. Nothing new to think out but it's such a part of our world view we forget it's there. We're hardwired that way.
And we can't forget about Lucifer. If God is dead, we should, as you suggested, have them kill each other off. I love that. Where does that leave us? And how, if at some level a large majority of people in the world don' t feel that God or Satan are real entities or forces at work in their lives or the world around them, do we set a stage to feel their loss without being gratuitously manipulative.
I like the idea you mentioned of a supernatural humanoid visiting someone in our plane of existence and falling in love.
What might an antagonist be?
The idea of an atheist getting scientific proof that God exists only to have God's ashes fall on his/her forehead is great.
==========H==========
Christianity does more than censor love, in my opinion. It does limit it, but it also displaces it. Love your wife as Christ loved the church? Love each other as I have loved you? And my personal favorite, anyone that loves is of God, and anyone who is not of God does not love. Give me a break. I want to love my wife as I love my wife. And we should love each other, not because some cosmic being loves us, but because we are all connected, and loving ourselves is loving each other is loving ourselves. The Net of Indra.
I think that a large population do believe in God, whether or not they act like it. So to hear that God – their God, whatever – is definitely gone, there would be a sense of loss. And I think it would settle on the population like a film, rather than the few Baptist churches that would burst into flames. That green image you sent that I turned to orange... that's the idea for me. The whole world would feel the repercussions, like the ash from a volcano, affecting everything with its microdust. The effect of their deaths is as much reflected in people's attitudes as anything, though I think there should be some natural effects. Maybe the ash thing is appropriate. Might be a starting place, anyway.
As far as antagonists, I think that The Order fits that bill. But we'll also need a contagonist. Think of it from a Star Wars point of view. The Order is The Empire. Darth Vader is the contagonist. The antagonist is diametrically opposed to the protagonist, but the contagonist tries to thwart the attempts of the protagonist. So I'd like to see a large, faceless organization with an attack dog. Our hero needs to be human, I think, but have an Obi Wan – that could be the former angel. Falling in love would be a cool angle, because it confuses him and makes him wonder if being an angel and loving none but God... idea... say that God does "absorb" love. Maybe the whole thing about censored and displaced love isn't just a man-invention as part of the religion, but that it's actually true? What if God diverts love for himself? Sheesh, what if we find out after God is dead just how selfish he really was? Really, is it possible for God to be a jerk, and Lucifer to simply be misunderstood? I don't want to get too sympathetic here, but when you consider the history between the two, Lucifer's motives aren't exactly hard to relate to. Maybe herein lies the yin-yang. God and Lucifer are truly counterparts. OH SHIT – what if they both die because they both HAVE to die? When God banished Lucifer, he didn't realize that he was making Lucifer his equal, actually bringing the whole universe into balance? Before time existed, there was God. God begins to create. If Adam and Eve were created without sin, there was no evil, and really, no free will yet. There was nothing bad to choose. So what made Adam and Eve any different from the angels? So God knows that he'll never have autonomous creations, and it's really bugging him. Getting love from the angels is sort of like cosmic rape – they have no choice. He wants some "honest" love. So... get this – he SETS LUCIFER UP to come against him in front of all creation. He makes Lucifer look like the bad guy and casts him off, thereby imposing a celestial yin-yang scenario. God is light, Lucifer is dark. They're intertwined. Consider: the entire religion of Christianity is solely to defeat Lucifer. Why does Lucifer have that much power? Why is God willing to sacrifice so many people (non-Christians) in his all-loving, all-knowing plan, his will that "none should perish"? What if it's to cover his tracks? Or what if Lucifer really is equal to God? In short, when God "ensures" Lucifer's defeat at Armageddon, he also destroys himself. The balance is gone, and the volitale "atom" breaks apart, causing a sort of nuclear explosion felt round the galaxy.
One other thing to consider – what if God isn't THE God. Like the idea of The Watcher in the Marvel comics. He can do everything we expect God can do, but he's just one of many. If you didn't know anything about gods and mythology and then met a demigod, wouldn't you think of that demigod as a god? You wouldn't stop to think: "wait, what if there's some kind of being even MORE powerful that this guy?"
==========R==========
God's/Satan's death - minutiae I know, but here it is. The "blood" of God fall's around the world like the sparks from a sparkler but with the weight of snow and actually fall far enough to catch in the hand without burning. At the same time hail falls to symbolize the death of Satan. There needs to be something magical about the hail but i'm not sure what. Adding to the nuclear explosion, it'd be cool to see glass, a car windshield maybe, freeze/frost over and melt in repeated flickering waves . And instead of shadows branding buildings light could "doge" buildings and glow at night.
==========H==========
Remember the hail in the exodus story? Hail with burning fire inside. There's this phenomena when the right sort of volcanic explosion happens where the lava goes so high it actually moisturizes the air, freezes, and then falls to earth with fire INSIDE THE ICE. Crazy. But it not only is reported in the Bible, it's been documented in Africa in the 1980s. We should steal that.